He found out that the button at the back of his head was gone while he was taking a shower.
“What the hell?” he whispered to himself, investigating the thick clump of hair almost hysterically, scratching, hoping to catch that familiar bump at the tip of his fingers. His skull seemed perfectly shaped like it had never been, capable of stealing the limelight if it ever featured in a horror movie. “What the hell?!” he whispered again and threw himself out of the shower. He was dripping of dirt still safe under a thick layer of hair on his legs, some desolate parts of his body still untouched by the water. He stood in front of the mirror, gave his head the weirdest angle to see its back. When he failed, he grabbed a hand mirror and got a reflection. There was no question of it. The button had disappeared.
He tried to get his head around this development, which was not much different than waking up and finding out that one of his arms or an eye or, what the hell, his whole head was gone. He was appalled. Confused. Clueless. And, worst of all, nonfunctioning.
“Honey, are you okay? Do you have any plans of coming out of the bathroom in the foreseeable future?”
His girlfriend, yes. He had to answer—he was sure that the right words existed, he had them before, had spoken them many times, but without the button, they felt like myths he had no reason to believe in except for his own intuition.
“Uh, I’ll—uh, be there in a second?”
* * *
He had his concerns but the breakfast made it obvious: after the highlights on the table were eaten, omelets and toast, he told his girlfriend that he was not going to be able to love her as much as he had or as much as she deserved anymore.
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
The cutlery came down. A gulp followed. Brows knitted. All the signs he had worked to avoid for years.
“I do not want to upset you. I’m serious. You see, there was this button—”
Then he went on to explain the button at the back of his head that, when pushed, allowed him to do everything exactly how it was supposed to be done, from things as mundane as cleaning the house or paying the bills to more complex concepts, like loving his girlfriend or feeling just the right amount of patriotism.
“Huh,” she said, with a dead stare. Her face took on an expression that he could not read, not without the button.
She grabbed the fork back, got herself an olive, at the first try at that, and ate it.
“You mad at me?”
“Why?”
“Well, because I pushed a button to love you?”
“You kept pushing the button, though, right? There was no other button that made you push the actual button?”
“Uh, no. Only one.”
“Then it’s okay. It means you chose to push it.”
She kept eating the cherry tomatoes on her plate as if nothing had changed, so smoothly that he briefly considered whether she had a button herself, somewhere safer than the back of the head, somewhere so discreet he never once saw her use.
* * * *
His first instinct was to ditch work, to stay at home and mourn for his dear button instead of taking part in a life that he knew he was going to half-ass. By noon, he was already going nuts. The worst part was that he knew he could’ve lost his mind better, had a way more efficient breakdown and an exemplary freak-out, if only he had his button.
He walked around the house, up and down. Tried to sleep but he couldn’t even keep his eyes closed properly. He kept eating junk food, tons of it. When he finally threw up, and in a sink like a fucking child, there were no signs of all those chips and chocolates in the small lake of puke, only the boring crème spinach from the previous night. This physical manifestation, though, was a valid excuse for him to admit he needed help beyond the button that even he was losing faith in.
He called up his sister, complained about his stomach, depicted certain scenes in detail that grossed the poor woman out, and when the natural flow of the conversation demanded, he narrated the mystery of the missing button for a second time that day.
She was silent on the other side of the line. He could hear the soft wind blowing at the garden of her office, her colleagues chattering, conversations over cigarettes.
“Oh, you son of a bitch,” she said finally. “Is that why you were so chill when grandma was hospitalized?!”
All this time, he was worried that people would have a lot of questions about a button on his head, technical ones, too: where it connected, what color it was, whether it caused any health issues, had a malfunction, ever worked in a different way when pushed. Now that he was sharing, he figured that no one was much troubled with the existence of such a button but rather its effect on them.
“That doesn’t mean I wasn’t worried about grandma back then,” he tried to explain. “I mean, beyond dealing with all that medical bureaucracy …”
“Bullshit.”
“This is hypocrisy, you know, what you’re doing,” he told his sister. “You need someone who can handle the insurance papers when a disaster strikes. Someone who’ll remember to lock the doors before leaving the house, who can sweet-talk the nurses, who can call up the family and deliver the news in a way that’ll not freak them out. You’d think less of me if I felt the same way you do. And as much as you do.”
He suddenly remembered the games they had played when they were little. He would pretend to scratch his head, push the button in secret, and just like that, he’d know exactly when he should let her win or humble her a bit.
“So, this thing, this button. It makes you function?”
“I wouldn’t say so,” he said. “It just makes me function in the right way.”
“I see. Got it.” He could picture her rubbing her chin, little know-it-all. “There are these pills—”
“I’m not crazy!”
“I know. I’m not talking about that. The pills that make you function. Antidepressants, antipsychotics, stimulants … They don’t have a much different effect than your button. They’re even better: only you have a button and it disappears, but everyone is using these pills and they’re available in pretty much every pharmacy.”
* * *
The following days were just a series of disappointments, both for him and the people around him.
You are finally forgetting your poor old mother.
Awfully quiet today, aren’t we?
Weren’t you supposed to buy some milk on your way home?
Last day to complete the form to continue your family plan.
Oh, honey, it’s okay. Lots of men of your age have such troubles.
Do five lessons today and you can have your streak back.
You have to keep a healthy diet, man. That’s a rookie mistake.
A gift card for my birthday? A GIFT CARD? Like, seriously?
How long had it been since he went for a run? When was the last time he read a book or finished a movie? Had a meaningful conversation? That he was actually present? That anything was really what it was supposed to be? The only thing that seemed to be unaffected by his imperfection was his job, which he found more eerie than relieving. At some point, unable to hold it in any longer, he checked in with his boss without fully opening his cards.
“Hey, quick question. Do you have any notes on my performance lately?”
“Like what?”
“Like, uh, I’m not as perfect as I usually am?”
“Wow, how modest of you.”
“Sorry, that came out wrong—”
“Doesn’t matter. I don’t care. Look, this job never demanded you or anyone else to be perfect anyway. You’re fine.”
He did consider those pills his sister mentioned, but as soon as it was an option, he kept having dreams in which all the pills were disappearing as soon as he attempted to take them out of the blister pack, his thumb pushing out only air, the pill factories burning down in purple-orange smoke, all the chemical companies declaring bankruptcy and recommending chamomile tea instead. He couldn’t shake the feeling that these were very plausible incidents. More unlikely things had happened, after all. He had had a button, and it had disappeared.
“How do you do it?” he asked his girlfriend, risking rudeness out of desperation. “How come you are at peace with screwing some things up, doing things subpar or, at best, just on par? How do you live with it?”
“You kidding me?” she said, unfazed. “I’m fucking amazing.”
* * *
That night, he went to bed with an unusual serenity: he had brushed his teeth but not flossed, mismatched his pajama top and bottom, lay slightly closer to the side of the bed than was ideal. His girlfriend was already asleep, cueing him in to join the rhythm of her quiet breath. The room was dark except for a single thread of light leaking from a crack where the two pieces of the curtain met. If he played deaf to the distant howling of the stray dogs or occasional honk of cars, it was completely silent. His body was weightless, almost nonexistent but for the smooth touch of the sheets and a slight itch on his right ankle. I can be happy, he thought, in the form of a statement. Most people are happy. He straightened himself up a bit and reached to his ankle as if the itch were the only thing between him and his happiness. Under a clump of hair, he felt the touch of cold metal. Startled, he pulled his leg up to see better, as best as he could in the dark without waking his girlfriend up. There was a small switch perfectly blended into his skin. It seemed to be down, which felt wrong immediately. He grabbed it with the tip of his fingers, had a wink of hesitation, and pushed it up.
There was a tingle first, a brief ringing in his ears, an almost visual static that reminded him of the old computer screens, and a parade of feelings he couldn’t identify—no banners, no uniforms, no cymbals. He checked the back of his head and there it was. His button. Oh, that lovely, reassuring, trustworthy button.
Unknown. [Fern leaves], about 1850. Photogenic drawing. Courtesy of The J. Paul Getty Museum.
Robin Dellabough, a poet and editor, has poems in Fifth Estate, Blue Unicorn, Gargoyle, Nassau Review, Lines + Stars, Negative Capability, The Westchester Review, Friends Journal, Tiny Spoon, Maryland Review, Footworks, and Mildred. She has studied with Kathleen Ossip, Amy Holman, and Suzanne Cleary at the Hudson Valley Writers Center.